It starts with a letter. Or worse—a front desk staff saying, “We’re sorry, we don’t take your insurance anymore.” You’re confused. Frustrated. You’ve been seeing this doctor for years, maybe even decades. Now what?
Table of Content
1.Why Your Doctor May No Longer Accept Your Medicare Advantage Plan
2. Step One: Confirm the Details with Your Doctor and Your Plan
3.Step Two: Understand Your Rights and Immediate Options
4.Step Three: Act Fast—Timing Is Everything
5.Step Four: Explore New Plan Options Without Losing Benefits
6.What If You’re Not Ready to Switch Doctors?
7.What Counts and What Doesn’t Toward Income
8.Still Not Sure You Qualify
Each year, countless seniors across New York and the U.S. are caught off guard when their trusted doctor suddenly stops accepting their Medicare Advantage plan. It’s happening more and more, especially in large cities like New York City, where hospitals and clinics constantly negotiate with insurers behind the scenes.
If this has happened to you, know this: you have rights, and you have options.
Why Your Doctor May No Longer Accept Your Medicare Advantage Plan
Doctors can leave a Medicare Advantage plan’s network for many reasons. Most often, it’s about money or red tape, not the patients. In New York, especially in the Bronx and Queens, we’ve seen providers leave networks because of low reimbursement rates, changes in contract terms, or billing complexity. Others decide to focus only on Original Medicare patients, private pay, or concierge medicine.
Sometimes it’s temporary. Sometimes it’s permanent. Either way, you deserve clear answers and a fast solution that keeps your care on track.
Step One: Confirm the Details with Your Doctor and Your Plan
Before you take any action, verify that your doctor has truly left the network. Sometimes front-desk staff are confused or uninformed.
Call your doctor’s office directly and ask if the change is permanent or temporary. Some practices drop plans temporarily due to payment delays but may rejoin later.
Call your insurance provider to confirm the network status of your doctor and whether they are in negotiations to resolve the issue.
Get it in writing if possible—either from the doctor or your plan. This documentation is useful if you file an appeal or request a Special Enrollment Period.
For updated network listings, check medicare.gov and your plan’s provider directory.
ADVERTISEMENT
Step Two: Understand Your Rights and Immediate Options
If your plan’s provider network has changed, and it significantly affects your access to care, you may be eligible for a Special Enrollment Period (SEP). This lets you switch to a different Medicare Advantage plan or back to Original Medicare with or without a Part D plan. Eligibility rules vary, so reviewing SEP guidelines on medicare.gov is important.
You may also qualify for continuity of care benefits. This means you can complete treatment with your current doctor even after they’ve left your plan’s network. Some plans are required to honor this when you’re in the middle of treatment, surgery prep, or a specialist referral.
Another option includes returning to Original Medicare with a Medigap plan, but this must be timed carefully due to guaranteed issue windows and potential underwriting.
At SecureSafer, our licensed brokers carefully examine your eligibility and coverage gaps to help you avoid penalties and make the most of your enrollment rights.
Step Three: Act Fast—Timing Is Everything
Medicare doesn’t wait. If you’re eligible for an SEP, you often have just 60 days from the network change to make a switch. After that, your ability to enroll may be restricted until the Annual Election Period (AEP) or Open Enrollment Period (OEP).
We’ve seen clients lose months of access to preferred doctors simply because they didn’t know their deadline. The sooner you call a licensed broker, the more options you’ll have.
At SecureSafer, we handle the entire process: checking plan availability, verifying your doctors and prescriptions, and submitting all paperwork before any deadlines.
Step Four: Explore New Plan Options Without Losing Benefits
Many seniors fear that switching plans means giving something up. But that’s not always the case. You may be able to switch to another Medicare Advantage plan that your doctor still accepts—and with similar or better benefits.
ADVERTISEMENT
We’ve helped clients move from high-premium plans to $0 premium options that still include dental, vision, and over-the-counter (OTC) card benefits. You might even discover new perks like gym reimbursements or transportation that your old plan didn’t offer.
To compare plans side-by-side, visit medicare.gov or contact our local agents who have access to plan data across Healthfirst, EmblemHealth, Fidelis Care, UnitedHealthcare, and MetroPlusHealth.
What If You’re Not Ready to Switch Doctors?
Some clients feel strongly about keeping their doctor—even if it means changing insurance plans. If that’s your situation, here are your options.
You can switch to a plan that your doctor still accepts, assuming you qualify for a SEP or it’s during the enrollment period. In rare cases, your doctor may offer private-pay options or accept out-of-network billing if your current plan allows it. Some clients even choose to return to Original Medicare with a Medigap plan, especially if their doctor participates in traditional Medicare.
We can review all of these scenarios with you and determine which one fits your health, budget, and timeline.
SecureSafer Will Guide You Every Step of the Way
You shouldn’t have to figure this out alone. At SecureSafer, we specialize in helping New Yorkers navigate these exact situations. We understand the local doctor networks, the plan politics behind the scenes, and how to legally advocate for your care.
We don’t just look up your options—we walk with you through the paperwork, explain confusing terms in plain English, and even call your doctor’s office for you if needed.
| Ready to protect your care and peace of mind? ✅ Call our SecureSafer team directly at SecureSafer.com or call (646) 444-2020 ✅ Request a policy review or switch evaluation today |
✅ Compliance Note:
This article is for educational purposes only and does not guarantee eligibility, approval, or savings. All benefit and legal claims are supported by medicare.gov, dfs.ny.gov, and health.ny.gov. SecureSafer is a licensed agency compliant with CMS and NYDFS guidelines.
ADVERTISEMENT