If you live in New York City, you might assume that Medicare is the same no matter which borough you’re in. But the truth is—your borough can affect which Medicare plans you see, what doctors you can visit, and even how much you pay.
Whether you live in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, or Staten Island, here’s how your location plays a bigger role than you think.
What’s Inside
- Plan Availability Can Vary by ZIP Code
- Staten Island and Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Differences
- Dual-Eligible Support May Differ by Borough
- Language and Enrollment Help Are More Available in Some Boroughs
- Final Word
Plan Availability Can Vary by ZIP Code
Many people are surprised to learn that Medicare Advantage plans are offered by county and even ZIP code. That means a plan available in the Bronx may not be available in Staten Island—or even in parts of Queens.
You can check which plans are offered in your exact ZIP code using the official Medicare Plan Finder. Enter your borough and ZIP to see all the options available in your area.
Hospital Networks Are Borough-Specific
Not every hospital system accepts every Medicare Advantage plan. For example, a plan that includes Montefiore Medical Center in the Bronx may not be accepted by NYU Langone in Brooklyn or Elmhurst Hospital in Queens.
Before enrolling in a plan, always confirm whether your preferred doctors or hospitals are in-network. Switching boroughs—or even neighborhoods—could affect your access to care.
Staten Island and Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Differences
While Original Medicare (Parts A & B) is standardized across the country, Medigap (supplemental) plans are sold by private companies, and availability and pricing can vary slightly from borough to borough.
Staten Island residents, for example, may find fewer Medigap plan choices or different premiums compared to those living in denser areas like Brooklyn or Queens.
Learn more about Medigap basics at Medicare.gov’s Medigap section.
Dual-Eligible Support May Differ by Borough
If you’re eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid, your borough can impact how quickly you’re able to access home care services or enroll in MLTC (Managed Long-Term Care).
Some boroughs have more program providers and service coordinators than others. For example, Queens and the Bronx tend to have more bilingual care managers, while Staten Island may have longer wait times for home evaluations.
ADVERTISEMENT
Language and Enrollment Help Are More Available in Some Boroughs
Queens and Brooklyn have large immigrant populations, which means more resources for language-accessible Medicare help. Community centers, senior groups, and local insurance brokers often host enrollment events in Spanish, Bengali, Chinese, Russian, and more.
In contrast, seniors in the Bronx or Staten Island may need to travel farther or rely on phone-based support for the same services.
Final Word
With the right info—and the right help—you can make a smart, penalty-free decision.
📞 Need one-on-one help? Our local experts are here to guide you through every step.
👉 Visit SecureSafer.com or call (646) 444-2020